Showing posts with label Rent Guidelines Board. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Rent Guidelines Board. Show all posts

Thursday, June 18, 2009

Another Increase From The Rent Guidelines Board

Summer is upon us (even though it doesn't look like it outside today) and for landlords of rent-stabilized buildings, it is time to salivate over how high the Rent Guidelines Board will raise rents. Of course, the tug of war will consist of the usual, "rents are too high" versus "our expenses are too high so we must have a large increase" and in the end the Board will pick something in the middle of the preliminary numbers. For this year, that means 2 to 4.5% for one year leases and 4 to 7.5% for two year leases.

Gothamist has some more details:

Of course, that doesn't sit well with the tenants. One told NY1, "A year and a half ago I had pneumonia and I was hospitalized due to lack of heat. They do not deserve an increase at all and many many other tenants are going through the same thing." And Manhattan Borough President Scott Stringer pointed out that last year's hikes—4.5% for one-year leases, 8.5% for two-year leases—was approved when landlords said energy prices would rise, when in reality they didn't. Stringer said, "So come clean, admit you made a mistake and the reason you freeze the rents is because you rent gauged last year based on a faulty set of assumptions." But landlord Jimmy Silber said, "If people want a rent freeze, let's have a freeze on real estate taxes and water and sewer taxes, plumbing increases and legal increases."
Basically, no matter how much screaming and shouting occurs from either side, there will be an increase of some sort. If people really want to change how this is done, they'll want to get rid of Pedro Espada and his GOP buddies so that the Democratic senate can get back to enacting reforms to help tenants get back rights that Republicans and a few developer-friendly Democrats (like Espada) have been stripping for the past few decades.

Friday, June 20, 2008

Rent Guidelines Board Sides With Landlords Again

Despite Christine Quinn's cries of being a rent-stabilized New Yorker, the Rent Guidelines Board ignored her humble roots and raised rent increases by the highest percentage in nearly 20 years. The board meeting was a crazy one down in Cooper Union, but of course it is every year. Renters want the price of living kept down and the landlords want to make more money off of their properties. Nothing changes, especially the RGB's ability to go along with the landlords.

From The NY Times:

At a meeting punctuated by ear-splitting whistle-blowing and shouting matches between sign-waving tenants and landlords, the city’s Rent Guidelines Board authorized rent increases of up to 4.5 percent on one-year leases and 8.5 percent on two-year leases.

The board also took the unusual and controversial step of authorizing a supplemental rent increase that affected only tenants who have lived in their apartments for six years or more. Owners of buildings with those tenants have the option of charging them the approved increases, or a $45 monthly increase for one-year leases or $85 for two-year leases, whichever is greater.

The last time the board approved a set of increases that were higher was in 1989, when one-year leases saw a 5.5 percent increase and two-year leases a 9 percent increase. In 2003, one-year leases increased 4.5 percent, but two-year leases increased 7.5 percent. Last year, the board approved increases of 3 percent on one-year leases and 5.75 percent on two-year leases.


Now you could say that at least the RGB didn't raise rates 14% like the landlords requested, but we know better that those weren't the rates they were after in the first place. Renters and landlords screamed at each other and even blew whistles over the issue. The Times called it a circus atmosphere but the clowns here are the board members who approved these rate hikes.

Now Christine Quinn will have something to complain about as she gears up for her Mayoral campaign. The downside is that with all of the other candidates, she has to worry that someone might call her out for siding with the ringleader of the circus in the last few years, that being Mayor Bloomberg and his use of zoning tricks.

Wednesday, June 11, 2008

Quinn Panders To NYC Renters

Speaker Christine Quinn is as we all know running for Mayor and if hollow words were a pre-requisite then she's all ready to move uptown to Gracie Mansion. Quinn had a few words for the Rent Guidelines Board this week and she certainly sounded tough. She's in favor of a state bill that would stop increases for a year, deny landlords with city code violations from rent hikes and connect renters' financials with rent hikes. It sounds good at first, but it doesn't come close to the heart of the problem.

From The NY Sun:

The director of government affairs for the Rent Stabilization Association, Frank Ricci, said the increases announced last month are modest and do not compare to the rising costs of utilities and increases in property taxes incurred by landlords.

"It is the property taxes that have been imposed by the City Council and the mayor that are driving the rents up," Mr. Ricci said. "If she wanted to help renters, she would make sure that there would be a reduction in the tax rate."

Between 2005 and 2007, rents on unregulated apartments in Manhattan increased 16%, a Citi Habitats report found.

The Rent Guidelines Board is composed of nine members appointed by the mayor, with two members representing tenants, two representing landlords, and five representing the general public.


The former "Idiot of the Week" isn't a stranger to screwing over renters for other things. That includes rolling over for Mayor Mike and his strong advocacy for pushing long-time New Yorkers with gentrifying zoning laws for the past few years. If Quinn really wanted to help renters, she'd go at this by looking at the big picture and not focusing on gimmicks.

Tuesday, May 06, 2008

Rent Guidelines Board Still In The Hands Of The Landlords

Every year there is a demand by renters to put a freeze on rent hikes and each time it is denied. Of course the landlords demand exorbitant hikes that would never see the light of day, so in the end the Rent Guidelines Board makes a "compromise" and raises the rates for renters across the city. Last year it was 3% for a one year lease and 5.75% for a two year and now the Board has tentatively passed a range for an eventual increase due out next month. This time around landlords wanted 9% and 14% increases respectively. Though that was voted down, the range (3.5-7% and 5.5 to 9.5%) is still ridiculously large and is slowly but surely kicking New Yorkers out of their city.

From The NY Times:

The proposed rent increases come as advocates for moderate and low-income housing and some elected officials have grown concerned about the affordability of the city’s rental market. Representative Anthony D. Weiner of Queens and Brooklyn released a study last month that found that roughly 500,000 New Yorkers were spending 50 percent or more of their income on housing.

Key factors in the range established by the board on Monday night are recent trends in housing affordability, tenant income and owner costs highlighted in three reports issued by the board’s staff last month. One of the reports, called the Price Index of Operating Costs, found that operating costs for rent-stabilized buildings increased 7.8 percent in the last year, in large part because of a rise in fuel costs and utility payments. The previous year, owners’ costs had risen by 5.1 percent. But another report showed that landlords of rent-stabilized units saw their net operating income — the earnings that remain after operating and maintenance expenses are paid — increase by 8.8 percent. That report was based on 2006 data.


If their incomes goes up while the costs of maintaining the buildings are at a similar rate, then there seems to be something fishy going on. Landlords in New York are notorious for cutting costs and skimping on the needs of their tenants. Even here in my own non-subsidized building, my heat mysteriously went out when we had that terrible cold snap in February of last year and when you call for something to get fixed....well, you get my point. What is important to note is that for all the whining and complaining that these poor, poor landlords do, they still make 37 cents on the dollar for their property. That isn't just a good deal, it should be classified as robbery.

Wednesday, April 30, 2008

NYC Landlords Looking To Screw Renters Deep Into Their Pockets Next Year

New York City hasn't been known for cheap real estate in quite some time. Buying a place is ridiculously expensive and rental prices are looking to try and match those that pay mortgages. Economists have told those who own real estate that renting is becoming more fiscally sound, but if the Rent Guidelines Board has its way, they'll be changing their financial planning tune.

From The Gothamist:

This year, landlords will be asking for 10% hikes for 1-year leases and 15% increases for 2-year leases. Last year, rents hikes were approved for 3% on 1-year leases and 5.75% on 2-year leases (in 2006, the hikes were 4.25% and 7.25%). Landlords point to rising fuel and other costs, but tenants say landlords are still making a lot of money and plan to fight the hike.

While many New Yorkers don't have rent stabilized apartments, the increases reflect real market concerns. Congressman Anthony Weiner--who is eying a run for Mayor next year--says almost one in three New Yorkers pays at least 50% of the income to landlords. Weiner said, "You should spend no more than a third of your income on rent. That is [now] seen more and more not like a rule of thumb, but a pipe dream." And last year, another possible 2009 mayoral candidate, Comptroller William Thompson, sent a letter imploring the Rent Guidelines Board not to raise rents.


Politicians are good at kicking and screaming for their constituents but recently have not done much in terms of actual results (remember the MTA fare hike a few months ago?). I do not want anyone to implore the RGB to do anything, I want it done to them. Rental prices are rising astronomically and it needs to stop. The glut and greed of landlords is ridiculous and we as a city let them get away with it. What we need to do is start calling the RGB, packing their hearings and demanding fair terms. A ten percent rise is hardly fair, it should be criminal.

Wednesday, June 27, 2007

Rent Raised Despite Large Protest

Well the Rent Guidelines Board met last night down at Cooper Union and raised our rents again. The Board passed a 3% increase on one year leases and 5.75% for two year deals. Ronald S. Languedoc who represents the renters wanted a rent freeze for the coming year, but was rejected in favor of the landlords of over one million apartments throughout the city. Higher rent increase proposals were also rejected, leaving the outcome to be in the middle. In the end, neither group was happy.

From The New York Times:

Tenants, some of whom came expecting a higher increase, were nonetheless unhappy. “They could have come down to about 4 and 2,” said Priscilla Durant, 61, who has lived in a rent-stabilized apartment in Washington Heights for 8 years. “That would have been good.”

Hector Lozano, 61, a landlord in her neighborhood, however, said that he was feeling the crush of high taxes and low rent. Mr. Lozano, who owns a 26-unit building in Washington Heights, said that he did not want to have to raise rents, but would this year have to pay $12,000 more in property taxes. “This is insane,” he said of the rental adjustments. “Some landlords are making a lot of money. But a lot of small landlords are going to hell and back.”


There should be a compromise, but only if the two sides are on an equal footing. The fact is that while tenants who do not pay their monthly rent are evicted, nothing happens to landlords who frequently rack up housing violations. With my own building included, landlords are allowed to get off with nothing more than a slap on the wrist while they get to charge higher and higher rents.

Maybe if the Housing Authority took better action against negligent building owners, tenants would be more willing to pay the extra rent. I know that the City Council passed a bill to target slumlords, but it is up to the Authority to carry out the council's bark with an appropriate bite.

Tuesday, June 26, 2007

Want A Say In The Cost Of Your Rent?

Unless you are lucky enough to own your little space in New York, the cost of rent is always an important of life in the city. For the most part we get the statement at the end of the month and pay it by the beginning of the next. But what if you could get your two cents on how rent is raised? If you are unable to reduce the increased prices by screaming or cajoling your landlord, you might want to come to the Rent Guidelines Board meeting tonight in The Great Hall at Cooper Union (7 East 7th at 3rd Avenue).

The final vote is tonight and this is the best time to make a lasting impression before the axe comes down. The landlords will be present to make their case on why your rent should be raised as high as possible. Yet for every one of them, there are many more of us. So come make your voice heard and fight the increasing cost of living in the city we all love.